Ben Lowndes #viewsoncomms

A perspective on PR, development and life in the South West

Talking about our devolution: what people told us about the deal

With all that’s happened since June, it’s easy to forget that there’s a big decision ahead about how the West of England runs its affairs.

The devolution deal for ‘greater Bristol’ won’t set most people’s pulses racing. But ask those who live and work here what’s important to them and many will say housing, transport, education, jobs or a combination of the above. As it happens, the West of England’s deal is geared towards addressing all of these issues.

On the table is £1bn to invest over 30 years in housing, transport and skills. Post #EUref, when ‘taking back control’ swayed views about our country’s future, handing responsibility for these issues to local areas seems an obvious step.

It’s probably worth five minutes’ of everyone’s time in the scheme of things.

But the deal comes with a catch that not all partners are happy about. The government wants a ‘metro mayor’, who would chair a combined authority to oversee the new investment. Despite signing the deal originally, North Somerset Council rejected it when it was put to its members.

The remaining three councils later agreed to consult on the proposal, which came to an end last Monday (15 August). A series of roadshows have been put on and an online questionnaire was promoted for people to respond to. I hope people engaged in the process, although the questionnaire was lengthy and difficult to complete. Early indications suggest it had a positive response.

What people told us

As our team is based in Bristol and has a keen interest in the city’s economic prosperity, we were keen to find out more about what businesses in the area think about the proposed deal and the metro mayor. Did their views mirror those of some councillors who fear a return of Avon County Council? Are they bothered about the metro mayor? Does any of it matter? 

To find out more, we put together a simple survey of our own. Five quick questions about people’s views on devolution, the deal and the metro mayor. We emailed it to around 500 of our contacts and promoted it on social media. More than 110 people who work in the area responded to the survey and provided a fascinating insight into local opinion on the deal.

Here are some of the headlines around what we found.

Most respondents want our area to have more responsibility for housing, transport and infrastructure. Almost 80% said councils should have more control over these areas.

Chart_Q2_160814
The overwhelming majority of respondents thought the investment proposed under the deal was either ‘very important’ or ‘quite important’. Just four people said that it was not what the area needs.

Chart_Q3_160814
Transport was the most important area for respondents, with housing and infrastructure gaining a similar number of responses. Sustainable energy, place-making and ‘not having a metro mayor’ were also cited as priority areas within individual responses.

Chart_Q4_160814
There was slightly less enthusiasm for a metro mayor, but a majority of respondents remained in favour of this when questioned.

Chart_Q5_160814

Deal, or no deal?

There is a caveat, of course: this was not a huge sample and a survey of this nature doesn’t ‘prove’ anything. But it was still large – and local enough – to illustrate what many people who work in the area think about key aspects of the deal.

People seem broadly supportive and want more influence over key areas, with some reservations. Some expressed scepticism about the ability of local authorities to deliver a programme of this nature. The disagreement between those parties over a deal that they all signed has done them few favours in this respect. It may also explain why the Northern Powerhouse – built around strong city-regions – has found more favour with government although questions are being raised about this [£].

Others (including elected members) expressed reservations about the metro mayor and an additional layer of local government. But those views weren’t widely expressed.

I hope the response the three councils have had to their consultation is sufficient to influence a positive outcome that will bring more powers to the West of England.

If they do, there is an opportunity for local leaders and the new mayor to demonstrate how they can make a difference. If they get that chance, I am sure most people will be behind them.

Thank you to everyone who took a few minutes to complete our survey. And if you participated in the consultation about the deal, I salute you!

A version of this blog post first appeared on PPS Group’s website.

One response to “Talking about our devolution: what people told us about the deal

  1. Pingback: Collaboration: more than a buzzword | Benlowndes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

Creative Business News

News, views and opinion from the UK's most creative region

FragmeNTs

from the National Trust archaeology team in the Stonehenge & Avebury World Heritage Site

bristoljames.com

a blog about adapting to the digital age

Colin Wiles

Commentary on current housing and planning issues

4,000 bricks

A place for housing, communications and political debate

AdeCapon's Blog

All things digital, marketing, football and happenings

John Wade

Joining up the planks

Simon Rogers

Data journalism and other curiosities

David Higgerson

Journalism, online, random thinking

Connecting Social Care and Social Media

Sharing resources to promote the use of Social Media in Social Care

John Popham's Random Musings

"Just trying to matter"

nick atkin

A collection of random views on housing, technology & running

Guido Fawkes

Parliamentary plots and conspiracy

A Sense of Place

Ronnie Hughes

Council Homes Chat

Busting myths about Council Housing by providing a platform for people's stories/experiences #CouncilHomesChat #SocialHousing

social for the people

Social media training and advice

TessaCoombes

Policy Politics Place

Heritage Calling

A Historic England Blog

Housing Comms

A platform to share all things housing comms related

Ben Black's Blog

Simple stories about communications. My ideas, tips and thoughts

Government Digital Service

Putting the public first in delivering digital public services

bromcomms

The communications team behind Bromford

Dan Slee

Social media, PR and digital communications in the public sector from the co-founder of comms2point0

Paul Taylor

Social Innovation. Customer Experience. Service Design

%d bloggers like this: