Ben Lowndes #viewsoncomms

A perspective on PR, development and life in the South West

Churnalism website highlights an ‘old news story’

The irony of The Guardian’s piece yesterday about a new website which exposes the extent to which news items are lifted from press releases is that (fascinating though it is) it is hardly ‘newsworthy’ that this happens.

The Media Standards Trust’s Churnalism website allows readers to paste press releases into a ‘churn engine’ and receive a rating which shows the percentage of any given article that has been reproduced from publicity material. It’s a very clever way of highlighting the issues surrounding the interface between journalism and PR, which is often portrayed as undermining the very fabric of democratic discourse in this country.

Much of this debate though does seems to assume that most PR is misleading and bad and that journalists are not doing their job if they even talk to public relations people. Some examples of churnalism on the website – where half-baked stories have generated media coverage – certainly point to sloppy practice.

But it is naive to think that the media could do its job effectively, with the limited resources it has, without having access to credible, quick and reliable information and content. This is what PR can provide, and does in a lot of cases.

It is also overlooked that PR is about more than churning out press releases, and can be brilliantly defined in the content and commentary assembled by the Media Standards Trust to launch its website. Giving The Guardian (which has the highest proportion of readers working in the media of any newspaper) exclusive access to the website, highlighting examples of bad practice by the tabloids (a hot topic if ever there was one) and providing video content to support the launch is classic PR in itself. Is this a bad thing? I don’t think anyone could say that it is, apart from perhaps those who have been implicated by it.

The website sparked interesting debates on Twitter this morning also, with some PR contacts wondering whether the website could be used as a measurement tool for the industry. Out of interest, I have just pasted a couple of paragraphs from recent HCA releases into the ‘churn engine’ and got nothing back. I am really not sure what to make of that!

One response to “Churnalism website highlights an ‘old news story’

  1. Pingback: Another view of how ‘churnalism’ works « Benlowndes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

Creative Business News

News, views and opinion from the UK's most creative region

FragmeNTs

from the National Trust archaeology team in the Stonehenge & Avebury World Heritage Site

bristoljames.com

a blog about adapting to the digital age

Colin Wiles

Commentary on current housing and planning issues

4,000 bricks

A place for housing, communications and political debate

AdeCapon's Blog

All things digital, marketing, football and happenings

John Wade

Joining up the planks

Simon Rogers

Data journalism and other curiosities

David Higgerson

Journalism, online, random thinking

Connecting Social Care and Social Media

Sharing resources to promote the use of Social Media in Social Care

John Popham's Random Musings

"Just trying to matter"

nick atkin

A collection of random views on housing, technology & running

Guido Fawkes

Parliamentary plots and conspiracy

A Sense of Place

Ronnie Hughes

Council Homes Chat

Busting myths about Council Housing by providing a platform for people's stories/experiences #CouncilHomesChat #SocialHousing

social for the people

Social media training and advice

TessaCoombes

Policy Politics Place

Heritage Calling

A Historic England Blog

Housing Comms

A platform to share all things housing comms related

Ben Black's Blog

Simple stories about communications. My ideas, tips and thoughts

Government Digital Service

Putting the public first in delivering digital public services

bromcomms

The communications team behind Bromford

Dan Slee

Social media, PR and digital communications in the public sector from the co-founder of comms2point0

Paul Taylor

Social Innovation. Customer Experience. Service Design

%d bloggers like this: